AFG vs. ERIE: American Financial vs. Erie Indemnity Stock Comparison
How do American Financial (AFG) and Erie Indemnity (ERIE) stack up? This page sets them side by side across company profile, performance and risk, profitability, growth, financial strength, dividends, and valuation, with selected fundamentals also measured against each stock's industry-group peers.
Company Profile
American Financial (AFG) and Erie Indemnity (ERIE) are both classified in the Property & Casualty Insurance sub-industry within the broader Insurance industry, placing them in the closest GICS peer bucket.
| Profile Item | AFG | ERIE |
|---|---|---|
| Name | American Financial Group Inc | Erie Indemnity Company Class A Common Stock |
| Country/Region | United States | United States |
| GICS Sector | Financials | Financials |
| GICS Industry Group | Insurance | Insurance |
| GICS Industry | Insurance | Insurance |
| GICS Sub-Industry | Property & Casualty Insurance | Property & Casualty Insurance |
| Market Capitalization | 12.79 billion USD | 14.28 billion USD |
| Currency | USD | USD |
| Exchange | NYSE | Nasdaq |
| Listing Date | March 17, 1980 | October 2, 1995 |
| Security Type | Common Stock | Common Stock |
Price Performance
Cumulative Growth
Trailing Returns
Calendar-Year Returns
Performance Metrics
| Metric | AFG | ERIE |
|---|---|---|
| Total Return (1Y) | 15.92% | -3.52% |
| Total Return (3Y, Annualized) | 20.24% | 0.54% |
| Total Return (5Y, Annualized) | 9.64% | 5.47% |
Risk Profile
Drawdown History
Return Distribution
Risk Metrics
| Metric | AFG | ERIE |
|---|---|---|
| Volatility (1Y, Annualized) | 17.44% | 38.16% |
| Beta (5Y) | 0.55 | 0.22 |
| Max Drawdown (5Y) | -23.85% | -60.87% |
| Avg. Volume (3M) | 386.95K | 236.89K |
Risk-Adjusted Performance
Risk-Return Positioning
Risk-Adjusted Metrics
| Metric | AFG | ERIE |
|---|---|---|
| Sharpe Ratio (1Y) | 0.67 | -0.20 |
| Sortino Ratio (1Y) | 1.02 | -0.29 |
Profitability
ROE (TTM)
Erie Indemnity (ERIE) at 23.70% sits in the top ROE quartile, while American Financial (AFG) at 21.57% is closer to the peer norm — stronger capital efficiency for ERIE.
AFG
Insurance industry group
21.57%
- Max
- 41.68%
- Q3
- 22.04%
- AFG
- 21.57%
- Median
- 14.81%
- Q1
- 8.79%
- Min
- -10.66%
ERIE
Insurance industry group
23.70%
- Max
- 41.68%
- ERIE
- 23.70%
- Q3
- 22.04%
- Median
- 14.81%
- Q1
- 8.79%
- Min
- -10.66%
Net Margin (TTM)
Both American Financial (AFG) at 12.28% and Erie Indemnity (ERIE) at 13.98% keep about the typical share of revenue as profit for their industries — neither bottom line stands out from peers.
AFG
Insurance industry group
12.28%
- Max
- 29.92%
- Q3
- 17.03%
- AFG
- 12.28%
- Median
- 10.97%
- Q1
- 6.21%
- Min
- -4.68%
ERIE
Insurance industry group
13.98%
- Max
- 29.92%
- Q3
- 17.03%
- ERIE
- 13.98%
- Median
- 10.97%
- Q1
- 6.21%
- Min
- -4.68%
Operating Margin (TTM)
Neither side reports a meaningful operating margin: for American Financial (AFG) in Insurance and Erie Indemnity (ERIE) in Insurance, funding costs are part of the core business, so net margin and ROE are the cleaner profitability reads.
Profitability Metrics
| Metric | AFG | ERIE |
|---|---|---|
| ROE (TTM) | 21.57% | 23.70% |
| ROA (TTM) | 2.55% | 13.48% |
| Net Margin (TTM) | 12.28% | 13.98% |
| Operating Margin (TTM) | -- | -- |
| Gross Margin (TTM) | -- | -- |
Growth
Revenue Growth
Erie Indemnity (ERIE) at 7.41% is around its peer norm for revenue growth, while American Financial (AFG) at -1.93% drops into the bottom quartile, signaling weaker demand or pricing momentum.
EPS Growth
Both American Financial (AFG) at -4.57% and Erie Indemnity (ERIE) at -6.88% land near their industries' usual EPS growth ranges, so bottom-line momentum looks broadly in line with peers on both sides.
Growth Metrics
| Metric | AFG | ERIE |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue Growth (YoY) | -1.93% | 7.41% |
| Revenue Growth (3Y CAGR) | 6.22% | 13.32% |
| EPS Growth (YoY) | -4.57% | -6.88% |
| EPS Growth (3Y CAGR) | -1.45% | 23.25% |
Financial Strength
Current Ratio (MRQ)
current ratio doesn’t apply on either side: American Financial (AFG) in Insurance and Erie Indemnity (ERIE) in Insurance both report balance sheets without a current/non-current split, so their short-term liquidity is better judged through regulatory and funding measures.
Debt / Equity (MRQ)
debt-to-equity ratio is set aside for both: American Financial (AFG) in Insurance and Erie Indemnity (ERIE) in Insurance run businesses where balance-sheet leverage is part of the model, so capital-adequacy and funding measures are the better gauges of balance-sheet risk.
Financial Strength Metrics
| Metric | AFG | ERIE |
|---|---|---|
| Current Ratio (MRQ) | -- | -- |
| Debt / Equity (MRQ) | -- | -- |
| Net Debt / EBITDA | -- | -- |
Dividends
Dividend Yield (TTM)
American Financial (AFG) at 2.31% delivers top-quartile income for its industry, while Erie Indemnity (ERIE) at 2.05% pays a more typical yield — both are credible income propositions, AFG the richer one.
AFG
Insurance industry group
2.31%
- Max
- 5.12%
- AFG
- 2.31%
- Q3
- 2.15%
- Median
- 0.98%
- Q1
- 0.00%
- Min
- 0.00%
ERIE
Insurance industry group
2.05%
- Max
- 5.12%
- Q3
- 2.15%
- ERIE
- 2.05%
- Median
- 0.98%
- Q1
- 0.00%
- Min
- 0.00%
Dividend Payout Ratio (TTM)
American Financial (AFG) at 28.71% pays out a band-typical share of earnings, while Erie Indemnity (ERIE) at 53.13% distributes more than its industry norm — less retained, thinner cover.
AFG
Insurance industry group
28.71%
- Max
- 76.67%
- Q3
- 35.18%
- AFG
- 28.71%
- Median
- 14.74%
- Q1
- 0.00%
- Min
- 0.00%
ERIE
Insurance industry group
53.13%
- Max
- 76.67%
- ERIE
- 53.13%
- Q3
- 35.18%
- Median
- 14.74%
- Q1
- 0.00%
- Min
- 0.00%
Dividend Metrics
| Metric | AFG | ERIE |
|---|---|---|
| Dividend Yield (TTM) | 2.31% | 2.05% |
| Dividend Payout Ratio (TTM) | 28.71% | 53.13% |
Valuation
P/E Ratio (TTM)
American Financial (AFG) at 12.61 is near its industry’s usual P/E ratio, while Erie Indemnity (ERIE) at 24.80 sits in the richer quartile — ERIE needs stronger growth or earnings quality to justify the premium.
AFG
Insurance industry group
12.61
- Max
- 28.37
- Q3
- 18.75
- AFG
- 12.61
- Median
- 12.23
- Q1
- 9.08
- Min
- 2.32
ERIE
Insurance industry group
24.80
- Max
- 28.37
- ERIE
- 24.80
- Q3
- 18.75
- Median
- 12.23
- Q1
- 9.08
- Min
- 2.32
P/S Ratio (TTM)
American Financial (AFG) at 1.54 is priced about in line with its industry on P/S ratio, while Erie Indemnity (ERIE) at 3.46 sits in the pricier quartile — ERIE costs more per dollar of sales.
AFG
Insurance industry group
1.54
- Max
- 4.03
- Q3
- 2.25
- AFG
- 1.54
- Median
- 1.23
- Q1
- 0.85
- Min
- 0.07
ERIE
Insurance industry group
3.46
- Max
- 4.03
- ERIE
- 3.46
- Q3
- 2.25
- Median
- 1.23
- Q1
- 0.85
- Min
- 0.07
P/B Ratio (MRQ)
American Financial (AFG) at 2.71 sits near its industry’s typical P/B ratio, while Erie Indemnity (ERIE) at 5.59 prices above its benchmark range — ERIE looks rich relative to book.
AFG
Insurance industry group
2.71
- Max
- 5.07
- Q3
- 2.79
- AFG
- 2.71
- Median
- 1.76
- Q1
- 1.23
- Min
- 0.30
ERIE
Insurance industry group
5.59
- ERIE
- 5.59
- Max
- 5.07
- Q3
- 2.79
- Median
- 1.76
- Q1
- 1.23
- Min
- 0.30
Valuation Metrics
| Metric | AFG | ERIE |
|---|---|---|
| P/E Ratio (TTM) | 12.61 | 24.80 |
| P/S Ratio (TTM) | 1.54 | 3.46 |
| P/B Ratio (MRQ) | 2.71 | 5.59 |
| Free Cash Flow Yield (TTM) | -- | -- |