ALLY vs. ERIE: A Head-to-Head Stock Comparison

Updated on October 10, 2025

Here’s a clear look at ALLY and ERIE, comparing key factors like historical performance, profitability, financial strength, growth, dividend, and valuation.

Company Profile

Symbol	ALLY	ERIE
Company Name	Ally Financial Inc.	Erie Indemnity Company
Country	United States	United States
GICS Sector	Financials	Financials
GICS Industry	Consumer Finance	Insurance
Market Capitalization	12.03 billion USD	17.14 billion USD
Exchange	NYSE	NasdaqGS
Listing Date	January 28, 2014	October 2, 1995
Security Type	Common Stock	Common Stock

Historical Performance

This chart compares the performance of ALLY and ERIE by tracking the growth of an initial $10,000 investment in each. Use the tabs to select the desired time period. Data is adjusted for dividends and splits.

ALLY vs. ERIE: Growth of a $10,000 investment over the past one year.

Historical Performance at a Glance

Symbol	ALLY	ERIE
5-Day Price Return	0.59%	4.16%
13-Week Price Return	-3.20%	-4.87%
26-Week Price Return	18.42%	-22.26%
52-Week Price Return	11.02%	-37.22%
Month-to-Date Return	-0.31%	3.00%
Year-to-Date Return	8.53%	-20.51%
10-Day Avg. Volume	4.17M	0.11M
3-Month Avg. Volume	3.29M	0.14M
3-Month Volatility	24.07%	26.01%
Beta	1.24	0.40

Profitability

Return on Equity (TTM)

ALLY

2.40%

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 32.87%
Q3: 21.72%
Median: 12.80%
Q1: 9.07%
Min: -3.88%

ALLY’s Return on Equity of 2.40% is in the lower quartile for the Consumer Finance industry. This indicates a less efficient generation of profit from its equity base when compared to its competitors.

ERIE

30.53%

Insurance Industry

Max: 30.96%
Q3: 18.76%
Median: 14.22%
Q1: 10.34%
Min: 1.73%

In the upper quartile for the Insurance industry, ERIE’s Return on Equity of 30.53% signals a highly effective use of shareholder capital to drive profitability compared to most of its peers.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Return on Equity (TTM) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Net Profit Margin (TTM)

ALLY

13.26%

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 19.68%
Q3: 17.11%
Median: 13.55%
Q1: 9.71%
Min: -0.75%

ALLY’s Net Profit Margin of 13.26% is aligned with the median group of its peers in the Consumer Finance industry. This indicates its ability to convert revenue into profit is typical for the sector.

ERIE

15.73%

Insurance Industry

Max: 26.78%
Q3: 14.69%
Median: 9.87%
Q1: 6.59%
Min: -3.51%

A Net Profit Margin of 15.73% places ERIE in the upper quartile for the Insurance industry, signifying strong profitability and more effective cost management than most of its peers.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Net Profit Margin (TTM) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Operating Profit Margin (TTM)

ALLY

15.87%

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 50.11%
Q3: 32.02%
Median: 19.92%
Q1: 14.90%
Min: -5.45%

ALLY’s Operating Profit Margin of 15.87% is around the midpoint for the Consumer Finance industry, indicating that its efficiency in managing core business operations is typical for the sector.

ERIE

17.49%

Insurance Industry

Max: 34.52%
Q3: 20.17%
Median: 14.46%
Q1: 9.62%
Min: -2.51%

In the Insurance industry, Operating Profit Margin is often not the primary measure of operational efficiency.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Operating Profit Margin (TTM) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Profitability at a Glance

Symbol	ALLY	ERIE
Return on Equity (TTM)	2.40%	30.53%
Return on Assets (TTM)	0.18%	21.10%
Net Profit Margin (TTM)	13.26%	15.73%
Operating Profit Margin (TTM)	15.87%	17.49%
Gross Profit Margin (TTM)	--	17.57%

Financial Strength

Current Ratio (MRQ)

ALLY

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 7.85
Q3: 4.26
Median: 2.28
Q1: 0.82
Min: 0.07

For the Consumer Finance industry, the Current Ratio is often not the most suitable measure of short-term liquidity.

ERIE

1.47

Insurance Industry

Max: 2.97
Q3: 1.37
Median: 0.54
Q1: 0.15
Min: 0.00

For the Insurance industry, the Current Ratio is often not the most suitable measure of short-term liquidity.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Current Ratio (MRQ) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Debt-to-Equity Ratio (MRQ)

ALLY

1.36

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 6.63
Q3: 3.60
Median: 2.40
Q1: 0.99
Min: 0.23

The Debt-to-Equity Ratio is often not the primary focus for assessing leverage in the Consumer Finance industry.

ERIE

0.00

Insurance Industry

Max: 1.25
Q3: 0.65
Median: 0.34
Q1: 0.23
Min: 0.00

The Debt-to-Equity Ratio is often not the primary focus for assessing leverage in the Insurance industry.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Debt-to-Equity Ratio (MRQ) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Interest Coverage Ratio (TTM)

ALLY

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 49.63
Q3: 28.11
Median: 4.75
Q1: 2.86
Min: -15.69

The Interest Coverage Ratio is often not a primary indicator of debt servicing capacity in the Consumer Finance industry.

ERIE

538.86

Insurance Industry

Max: 43.68
Q3: 21.45
Median: 9.67
Q1: 3.55
Min: -5.73

The Interest Coverage Ratio is often not a primary indicator of debt servicing capacity in the Insurance industry.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Interest Coverage Ratio (TTM) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Financial Strength at a Glance

Symbol	ALLY	ERIE
Current Ratio (MRQ)	--	1.47
Quick Ratio (MRQ)	--	1.39
Debt-to-Equity Ratio (MRQ)	1.36	0.00
Interest Coverage Ratio (TTM)	--	538.86

Growth

Revenue Growth

ALLY vs. ERIE: A side-by-side comparison of their Revenue Growth for the MRQ (YoY), TTM (YoY), 3-Year CAGR, and 5-Year CAGR periods.

EPS Growth

ALLY vs. ERIE: A side-by-side comparison of their EPS Growth for the MRQ (YoY), TTM (YoY), 3-Year CAGR, and 5-Year CAGR periods.

Dividend

Dividend Yield (TTM)

ALLY

3.96%

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 7.21%
Q3: 3.38%
Median: 2.39%
Q1: 0.67%
Min: 0.00%

With a Dividend Yield of 3.96%, ALLY offers a more attractive income stream than most of its peers in the Consumer Finance industry, signaling a strong commitment to shareholder returns.

ERIE

1.64%

Insurance Industry

Max: 9.80%
Q3: 5.18%
Median: 3.58%
Q1: 2.07%
Min: 0.00%

ERIE’s Dividend Yield of 1.64% is in the lower quartile for the Insurance industry. This suggests the company’s strategy likely favors retaining earnings for growth over providing a high dividend income.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Dividend Yield (TTM) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Dividend Payout Ratio (TTM)

ALLY

33.71%

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 145.89%
Q3: 88.89%
Median: 25.97%
Q1: 9.25%
Min: 0.00%

ALLY’s Dividend Payout Ratio of 33.71% is within the typical range for the Consumer Finance industry, suggesting a balanced approach between shareholder payouts and company reinvestment.

ERIE

39.35%

Insurance Industry

Max: 169.40%
Q3: 85.57%
Median: 53.26%
Q1: 23.68%
Min: 0.00%

ERIE’s Dividend Payout Ratio of 39.35% is within the typical range for the Insurance industry, suggesting a balanced approach between shareholder payouts and company reinvestment.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Dividend Payout Ratio (TTM) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Dividend at a Glance

Symbol	ALLY	ERIE
Dividend Yield (TTM)	3.96%	1.64%
Dividend Payout Ratio (TTM)	33.71%	39.35%

Valuation

Price-to-Earnings Ratio (TTM)

ALLY

35.72

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 35.93
Q3: 20.63
Median: 12.65
Q1: 9.73
Min: 3.96

A P/E Ratio of 35.72 places ALLY in the upper quartile for the Consumer Finance industry. This high valuation relative to peers suggests the market holds elevated expectations for the company’s future growth.

ERIE

24.01

Insurance Industry

Max: 30.75
Q3: 18.11
Median: 12.67
Q1: 9.66
Min: 2.87

A P/E Ratio of 24.01 places ERIE in the upper quartile for the Insurance industry. This high valuation relative to peers suggests the market holds elevated expectations for the company’s future growth.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Price-to-Earnings Ratio (TTM) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Price-to-Sales Ratio (TTM)

ALLY

0.89

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 3.79
Q3: 2.71
Median: 1.91
Q1: 1.14
Min: 0.61

In the lower quartile for the Consumer Finance industry, ALLY’s P/S Ratio of 0.89 indicates its revenue is valued more conservatively than most of its peers. This could present a compelling opportunity if the market has overlooked its sales-generating capabilities.

ERIE

3.78

Insurance Industry

Max: 3.41
Q3: 1.88
Median: 1.22
Q1: 0.80
Min: 0.23

With a P/S Ratio of 3.78, ERIE trades at a valuation that eclipses even the highest in the Insurance industry. This implies the market has priced in exceptionally optimistic scenarios for future revenue growth, posing considerable valuation risk.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Price-to-Sales Ratio (TTM) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Price-to-Book Ratio (MRQ)

ALLY

0.82

Consumer Finance Industry

Max: 3.80
Q3: 2.83
Median: 2.02
Q1: 1.18
Min: 0.26

ALLY’s P/B Ratio of 0.82 is in the lower quartile for the Consumer Finance industry. From a value investing perspective, this is favorable, as it suggests the stock is trading at a discount to its net asset value and may offer a greater margin of safety.

ERIE

8.30

Insurance Industry

Max: 4.57
Q3: 2.56
Median: 1.88
Q1: 1.20
Min: 0.17

At 8.30, ERIE’s P/B Ratio is at an extreme premium to the Insurance industry. This signifies that the market’s valuation is heavily reliant on future potential rather than its current net asset value, which can be a high-risk proposition.

ALLY vs. ERIE: A comparison of their Price-to-Book Ratio (MRQ) against their respective Consumer Finance and Insurance industry benchmarks.

Valuation at a Glance

Symbol	ALLY	ERIE
Price-to-Earnings Ratio (TTM)	35.72	24.01
Price-to-Sales Ratio (TTM)	0.89	3.78
Price-to-Book Ratio (MRQ)	0.82	8.30
Price-to-Free Cash Flow Ratio (TTM)	14.39	26.60