AFG vs. SIGI: A Head-to-Head Stock Comparison
Updated onHere’s a clear look at AFG and SIGI, comparing key factors like historical performance, profitability, financial strength, growth, dividend, and valuation.
Company Overview
AFG’s market capitalization of 10.64 billion USD is substantially larger than SIGI’s 5.25 billion USD, indicating a significant difference in their market valuations.
With betas of 0.71 for AFG and 0.49 for SIGI, both stocks show similar sensitivity to overall market movements.
| Symbol | AFG | SIGI |
|---|---|---|
| Company Name | American Financial Group, Inc. | Selective Insurance Group, Inc. |
| Country | US | US |
| Sector | Financial Services | Financial Services |
| Industry | Insurance - Property & Casualty | Insurance - Property & Casualty |
| CEO | Stephen Craig Lindner | John Joseph Marchioni CPCU |
| Price | 127.43 USD | 86.33 USD |
| Market Cap | 10.64 billion USD | 5.25 billion USD |
| Beta | 0.71 | 0.49 |
| Exchange | NYSE | NASDAQ |
| IPO Date | March 17, 1980 | March 17, 1980 |
| ADR | No | No |
Historical Performance
This chart compares the performance of AFG and SIGI by tracking the growth of an initial $10,000 investment in each. Use the tabs to select the desired time period.
Data is adjusted for dividends and splits.
Profitability
Return on Equity
AFG
17.81%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 28.14%
- Q3
- 17.51%
- Median
- 12.75%
- Q1
- 8.26%
- Min
- 0.61%
In the upper quartile for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, AFG’s Return on Equity of 17.81% signals a highly effective use of shareholder capital to drive profitability compared to most of its peers.
SIGI
7.52%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 28.14%
- Q3
- 17.51%
- Median
- 12.75%
- Q1
- 8.26%
- Min
- 0.61%
SIGI’s Return on Equity of 7.52% is in the lower quartile for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This indicates a less efficient generation of profit from its equity base when compared to its competitors.
Return on Invested Capital
AFG
27.67%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 21.89%
- Q3
- 10.09%
- Median
- 3.90%
- Q1
- 0.89%
- Min
- -7.26%
Return on Invested Capital is often not a primary measure of capital efficiency in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry.
SIGI
2.41%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 21.89%
- Q3
- 10.09%
- Median
- 3.90%
- Q1
- 0.89%
- Min
- -7.26%
Return on Invested Capital is often not a primary measure of capital efficiency in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry.
Net Profit Margin
AFG
13.06%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 21.98%
- Q3
- 13.09%
- Median
- 9.18%
- Q1
- 6.10%
- Min
- 2.13%
AFG’s Net Profit Margin of 13.06% is aligned with the median group of its peers in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This indicates its ability to convert revenue into profit is typical for the sector.
SIGI
4.70%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 21.98%
- Q3
- 13.09%
- Median
- 9.18%
- Q1
- 6.10%
- Min
- 2.13%
Falling into the lower quartile for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, SIGI’s Net Profit Margin of 4.70% indicates weaker profitability. This means the company retains a smaller portion of each dollar in sales as profit compared to its competitors.
Operating Profit Margin
AFG
14.02%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 31.70%
- Q3
- 17.32%
- Median
- 12.57%
- Q1
- 7.38%
- Min
- 4.31%
AFG’s Operating Profit Margin of 14.02% is around the midpoint for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, indicating that its efficiency in managing core business operations is typical for the sector.
SIGI
6.19%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 31.70%
- Q3
- 17.32%
- Median
- 12.57%
- Q1
- 7.38%
- Min
- 4.31%
SIGI’s Operating Profit Margin of 6.19% is in the lower quartile for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This indicates weaker profitability from core operations, which may stem from inefficiencies or competitive pressures on pricing.
Profitability at a Glance
| Symbol | AFG | SIGI |
|---|---|---|
| Return on Equity (TTM) | 17.81% | 7.52% |
| Return on Assets (TTM) | 2.64% | 1.65% |
| Return on Invested Capital (TTM) | 27.67% | 2.41% |
| Net Profit Margin (TTM) | 13.06% | 4.70% |
| Operating Profit Margin (TTM) | 14.02% | 6.19% |
| Gross Profit Margin (TTM) | 69.59% | 99.10% |
Financial Strength
Current Ratio
AFG
--
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 51.52
- Q3
- 30.84
- Median
- 20.50
- Q1
- 6.61
- Min
- 0.41
Current Ratio data for AFG is currently unavailable.
SIGI
180.68
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 51.52
- Q3
- 30.84
- Median
- 20.50
- Q1
- 6.61
- Min
- 0.41
SIGI’s Current Ratio of 180.68 is exceptionally high, placing it well outside the typical range for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This indicates a very strong liquidity position, though such a high ratio may also suggest that the company is not using its assets efficiently to generate profits.
Debt-to-Equity Ratio
AFG
0.34
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 0.58
- Q3
- 0.36
- Median
- 0.27
- Q1
- 0.14
- Min
- 0.01
AFG’s Debt-to-Equity Ratio of 0.34 is typical for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, indicating its use of leverage is in line with the sector norm. This suggests a balanced approach to its capital structure.
SIGI
0.28
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 0.58
- Q3
- 0.36
- Median
- 0.27
- Q1
- 0.14
- Min
- 0.01
SIGI’s Debt-to-Equity Ratio of 0.28 is typical for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, indicating its use of leverage is in line with the sector norm. This suggests a balanced approach to its capital structure.
Interest Coverage Ratio
AFG
11.29
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 39.40
- Q3
- 22.24
- Median
- 12.38
- Q1
- 6.68
- Min
- -12.40
AFG’s Interest Coverage Ratio of 11.29 is positioned comfortably within the norm for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, indicating a standard and healthy capacity to cover its interest payments.
SIGI
9.86
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 39.40
- Q3
- 22.24
- Median
- 12.38
- Q1
- 6.68
- Min
- -12.40
SIGI’s Interest Coverage Ratio of 9.86 is positioned comfortably within the norm for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, indicating a standard and healthy capacity to cover its interest payments.
Financial Strength at a Glance
| Symbol | AFG | SIGI |
|---|---|---|
| Current Ratio (TTM) | -- | 180.68 |
| Quick Ratio (TTM) | -- | 180.68 |
| Debt-to-Equity Ratio (TTM) | 0.34 | 0.28 |
| Debt-to-Asset Ratio (TTM) | 0.05 | 0.06 |
| Net Debt-to-EBITDA Ratio (TTM) | 0.31 | 2.57 |
| Interest Coverage Ratio (TTM) | 11.29 | 9.86 |
Growth
The following charts compare key year-over-year (YoY) growth metrics for AFG and SIGI. These metrics are based on the companies’ annual financial reports.
Revenue Growth
Earnings Per Share (EPS) Growth
Free Cash Flow Growth
Dividend
Dividend Yield
AFG
7.15%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 8.17%
- Q3
- 3.10%
- Median
- 1.79%
- Q1
- 0.00%
- Min
- 0.00%
With a Dividend Yield of 7.15%, AFG offers a more attractive income stream than most of its peers in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, signaling a strong commitment to shareholder returns.
SIGI
1.73%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 8.17%
- Q3
- 3.10%
- Median
- 1.79%
- Q1
- 0.00%
- Min
- 0.00%
SIGI’s Dividend Yield of 1.73% is consistent with its peers in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, providing a dividend return that is standard for its sector.
Dividend Payout Ratio
AFG
94.24%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 115.20%
- Q3
- 35.27%
- Median
- 22.19%
- Q1
- 3.16%
- Min
- 0.00%
AFG’s Dividend Payout Ratio of 94.24% is in the upper quartile for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This indicates a strong commitment to shareholder returns but also suggests that a smaller portion of earnings is retained for reinvestment compared to many peers.
SIGI
40.80%
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 115.20%
- Q3
- 35.27%
- Median
- 22.19%
- Q1
- 3.16%
- Min
- 0.00%
SIGI’s Dividend Payout Ratio of 40.80% is in the upper quartile for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This indicates a strong commitment to shareholder returns but also suggests that a smaller portion of earnings is retained for reinvestment compared to many peers.
Dividend at a Glance
| Symbol | AFG | SIGI |
|---|---|---|
| Dividend Yield (TTM) | 7.15% | 1.73% |
| Dividend Payout Ratio (TTM) | 94.24% | 40.80% |
Valuation
Price-to-Earnings Ratio
AFG
13.36
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 35.83
- Q3
- 23.28
- Median
- 14.49
- Q1
- 11.91
- Min
- 4.47
AFG’s P/E Ratio of 13.36 is within the middle range for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This suggests its valuation is in line with the sector average, representing neither a significant premium nor a discount compared to its peers.
SIGI
22.42
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 35.83
- Q3
- 23.28
- Median
- 14.49
- Q1
- 11.91
- Min
- 4.47
SIGI’s P/E Ratio of 22.42 is within the middle range for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This suggests its valuation is in line with the sector average, representing neither a significant premium nor a discount compared to its peers.
Forward P/E to Growth Ratio
AFG
1.41
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 2.53
- Q3
- 1.90
- Median
- 1.33
- Q1
- 0.86
- Min
- 0.01
AFG’s Forward PEG Ratio of 1.41 is within the middle range of its peers in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This suggests a reasonable balance between the stock’s price and its expected growth, aligning with sector valuation norms.
SIGI
1.82
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 2.53
- Q3
- 1.90
- Median
- 1.33
- Q1
- 0.86
- Min
- 0.01
SIGI’s Forward PEG Ratio of 1.82 is within the middle range of its peers in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This suggests a reasonable balance between the stock’s price and its expected growth, aligning with sector valuation norms.
Price-to-Sales Ratio
AFG
1.74
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 3.76
- Q3
- 2.39
- Median
- 1.80
- Q1
- 1.01
- Min
- 0.50
The P/S Ratio is often not a primary valuation tool in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry.
SIGI
1.05
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 3.76
- Q3
- 2.39
- Median
- 1.80
- Q1
- 1.01
- Min
- 0.50
The P/S Ratio is often not a primary valuation tool in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry.
Price-to-Book Ratio
AFG
2.43
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 5.34
- Q3
- 2.95
- Median
- 1.92
- Q1
- 1.31
- Min
- 0.52
AFG’s P/B Ratio of 2.43 is within the conventional range for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This shows a balanced market view, where the stock’s price is neither at a significant premium nor a discount to the book value of its peers.
SIGI
1.61
Insurance - Property & Casualty Industry
- Max
- 5.34
- Q3
- 2.95
- Median
- 1.92
- Q1
- 1.31
- Min
- 0.52
SIGI’s P/B Ratio of 1.61 is within the conventional range for the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. This shows a balanced market view, where the stock’s price is neither at a significant premium nor a discount to the book value of its peers.
Valuation at a Glance
| Symbol | AFG | SIGI |
|---|---|---|
| Price-to-Earnings Ratio (P/E, TTM) | 13.36 | 22.42 |
| Forward PEG Ratio (TTM) | 1.41 | 1.82 |
| Price-to-Sales Ratio (P/S, TTM) | 1.74 | 1.05 |
| Price-to-Book Ratio (P/B, TTM) | 2.43 | 1.61 |
| Price-to-Free Cash Flow Ratio (P/FCF, TTM) | 7.47 | 4.23 |
| EV-to-EBITDA (TTM) | 16.68 | 17.50 |
| EV-to-Sales (TTM) | 1.77 | 1.23 |